Wednesday 14 April 2021

Part 5 John ‘Jack Roe’ Sproule of Curraghamulkin – the Second Wife

 I found this little piece in a Volume called ‘Notes and Queries’, a strange volume of random notes on different families published in 1895. It actually brought a tear to my eye when I saw it, for there was my fellow Sproule researcher, Jack Elder, doing exactly what I am trying to do now, over 120 years later. He was asking a question of the Edwards and LaVie family historian to try to find the answer to the riddle of the wife of John ‘Jack Roe’ Sproule of Curraghamulkin. Jack Elder couldn’t let this go, but he didn’t get the answer that would help him. Unbeknownst to him, the question that Elder had asked in this little note gave me, one of his successors,  the key to unlock the answer.

The wife of John Sproule of Curraghamulkin was known to the Edwards family historians. She was Martha Sproule of Golan, the daughter of Robert Sproule of Golan and Martha Edwards of Kilcroagh. The Edwards family were the landowning family in the area. Martha was first cousin of Hugh Edwards of Castlegore, a Castle a mile to the south west of Castlederg. In around 1668, their ancestor, another Hugh Edwards, had purchased the whole of the ‘Manor of Hastings’, a large estate all round Castlederg. They were an affluent family living in their Castle, until the family crashed and burned round about this time at the end of the 1700s.

The Edwards family historians knew that Martha Sproule of Golan who married John ‘Jack Roe’ Sproule of Curraghamulkin, was the 2nd cousin of Hugh Edwards of Castlegore. That was a fact. And yet Jack Elder in this ‘Notes and Queries’ note, was asking them to explain something that John Inch had written. The Edwards Historian answer in this ‘Notes and Queries’ volume was that John Inch was wrong.

Now I know it, and Jack Elder definitely knew it. When it came to family history, John Inch was always right! (Or nearly always!) John Inch was born in 1795 in Ederny Bridge, Fermanagh and he was an avid Sproule family historian from a young age. He collected family histories in Ireland before he left for New Brunswick in Canada in 1820, and over there, he gathered even more Sproule information from the established Sproule settlers there.

His precious 40 precious pages of Sproule information and family trees were seen by Jack Elder at the end of the 1800s. It was on these that Jack Elder based all his early Sproule trees.

Elder knew, what I now know, that John Inch was very, very rarely wrong. All the research backs up exactly what he wrote in those 40 pages.

And yet there was a note of John Inch’s that puzzled Jack Elder greatly. It was about Elizabeth, his grandmother who had married John ‘Jack Roe’ Sproule of Curraghamulkin. Elder knew that John Inch grew up knowing his grandmother in Ireland, he talked to her, and he recorded what she said. Surely he couldn’t be wrong?

Elder tells us in this ‘Notes and Queries’ volume that what John Inch wrote was:

“Of this family was Lady Ross, named Elizabeth Edwards, who owned Castlegore estate in her own right. This family of Edwardses and our ancestors of the Sproule family must have been related, for I have heard my grandmother, Elizabeth Sproule (wife of John Sproule of Glenvale, Co Tyrone), say that she and lady Ross were first cousins”

P. 289 Notes and Queries, https://archive.org/details/s8notesqueries07londuoft/page/290/mode/2up

John Inch was saying that his grandmother was 1st cousin to Lady Ross, who is Olivia Edwards of Castlegore. She was 1st cousin – not 2nd cousin.

But now we know that the person who was 2nd cousin to Lady Ross, Olivia Edwards, was  Martha Sproule of Golan, who was the first wife of John of Curraghamulkin.

And we know that John Inch was talking about a completely different person. She was Elizabeth, 2nd wife of John Sproule of Curraghamulkin.

John Inch is telling us that his grandmother Elizabeth is another Edwards, and that she is, in fact, 1st cousin to Olivia Edwards of Castlegore. 

Elizabeth, 2nd wife and widow of John ‘Jack Roe’ Sproule of Curraghamulkin, is Elizabeth Edwards, the daughter of a brother of Hugh Edwards of Castlegore.


Part 1 - John ‘Jack Roe’ Sproule of Curraghamulkin, The Context

Part 2 - John ‘Jack Roe’ Sproule of Curraghamulkin, Pieces of the Jigsaw.

Part 3 - John ‘Jack Roe’ Sproule of Curraghamulkin, the Record of his Death

Part 4 - John ‘Jack Roe’ Sproule of Curraghamulkin – and the Second Wife


No comments:

Post a Comment